Authorities found dead animals scattered all over a couple’s property in Beaverhead County in southwestern Montana this week, including dead goats sticking out of 3 feet of feces in a trailer and a decaying dog with a collar still around its neck in the back of a car.
Robert Riley
There were many living goats, horses, pigs and other animals, too, but they were in unfit living condition and fed only trash thrown onto the ground, according to Beaverhead County sheriff’s deputies.
The owners of the property off of Chreston Lane, Robert Riley and Constance Riley, both 71, were detained Tuesday and made initial court appearances in Beaverhead County Justice Court on Thursday on charges of aggravated animal cruelty and littering.
Constance Riley
They were released on their own recognizance but they cannot have any animals on their property. Aggravated animal cruelty is a felony so the case will ultimately be transferred to state District Court, where they will be arraigned.
Beaverhead County Sheriff David Wendt said Wednesday it was one of the largest and most heinous cases of animal cruelty the office has investigated. His officers were able to seize 47 animals that were still living.
According a probable cause affidavit, deputies and state troopers told the Rileys they had a search warrant for the property and they were detained while it was carried out.
“We found unfit living conditions for all animals,” the affidavit says. “The goats, horses, pigs and an alpaca were living in an open pen near the top of the property and were fed only trash which was thrown on the ground.”
There was bread still in wrappers thrown about, it says, and the animals appeared to be consuming the plastic wrappers along with bread and other human foods thrown into the pen. One goat was dead.
There was a trailer home next to the pen.
“Inside the trailer there was approximately 3 feet deep in animal feces and there were parts of dead goats sticking out of the top with the rest of a dead goat appearing to be buried by the feces,” the affidavit says.
There were two troughs with dark green water and another filled only with trash. Living pigs appeared to be covered in skin sores and one of the pigs struggled to walk “with both back legs partially disabled,” the affidavit says.
The horses appeared to have no dietary regulation and the goats were skittish and “clearly not accustomed to human interaction,” it says.
Open areas of the property were scattered with dead animals, authorities said. Many appeared to be goats but “were decayed beyond recognition.”
There was another trailer home on the property and when deputies opened the door, a dead goat was in the entryway. There were numerous cats inside but they were feral and could not be captured.
“A car on top of the property had a heavily decayed dead dog in the back seat covered partially by a blanket, its collar still around its neck,” the affidavit said.
The living animals seized included horses, goats, alpacas, pigs, chickens, geese, dogs, turkeys and cats.
___
50 years of the ESA: Explore this series, in photos
Erin Fenger, conflict prevention specialist for Montana Fish, Wildlife and Park, throws old cattle bones into a dump trailer on a ranch outside Valier, Mont. in Sept. 2023. Montana FWP’s prairie bear team routinely picks up bone pits and carcasses from ranches to prevent grizzly bear attraction to the operations.
Henry Becker, pets Zia, an anatolian shepherd, on the Stickleg Ranch outside Conrad, Mont. in Sept. 2023.
Range rider Sigrid Olson rides her horse Jake on public land in search of cattle outside Potomac, Mont. in Oct. 2023.
Range rider Sigrid Olson rides her horse Jake on public land in search of cattle outside Potomac, Mont., in October 2023.
Range rider Sigrid Olson rides her horse Jake on public land in search of cattle outside Potomac, Mont. in Oct. 2023.
A major aspect of Sigrid Olson’s job as a range riding is documenting the condition of cattle on the range and signs of predators in the area. She produces a report from her notes that she shares with producers and wildlife agencies.
Range rider Sigrid Olson poses for a portrait after a day of range riding outside Potomac, Mont. in Oct. 2023.
Range rider Sigrid Olson loosens the saddle on her horse Jake after a day of range riding outside Potomac, Mont. in Oct. 2023.
Kristina Harkins of the Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife & Parks walks down a hillside near Ambrose Creek northeast of Stevensville after using a radio receiver to locate sharp-tailed grouse on Nov. 16. Harkins is a field coordinator for FWP's effort to reintroduce the species west of the Continental Divide, where they haven't been seen for decades.
Harkins uses a handheld radio antenna to listen for collared sharp-tailed grouse near the MPG Ranch in the northern Bitterroot Valley on Nov. 16.
Kristina Harkins, in the driver seat of an FWP truck near the MPG Ranch Nov. 16, listens for signals from radio-collared sharp-tailed grouse using an omnidirectional antenna mounted atop the truck cab.
Male sharp-tailed grouse dance on a lek in early morning light in spring 2023.
An estimated 300 wolverines prowl the snowy elevations of the Rocky Mountains in Montana, Idaho, Wyoming and parts of Washington, Utah and Colorado. Their hard-to-find nature has challenged the ability of biologists to confirm wolverines' population in the Lower 48 states.
A wolverine triggers a remote camera in the Helena National Forest. The elusive carnivore depends on deep snow for breeding and scavenging food. Climate change and habitat fragmentation have made it a candidate for listing under the Endangered Species Act on its 50th anniversary.
Staff from the Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife and Parks re-introduced Arctic grayling in French Creek in the Mount Haggin Wildlife Management Area in early October The fish have genetic ties to river-dwelling Arctic grayling in the Big Hole River.
Fish, Wildlife and Parks Fisheries Biologist Jim Olsen, right, and Region Three Supervisor Marina Yoshioka hold buckets for transporting Arctic grayling during a repopulation project on French Creek on Oct. 2 in the Mount Haggin Wildlife Management Area.
Fish, Wildlife and Parks Fisheries Technician Lance Breen releases Arctic grayling into French Creek during a repopulation project on Oct. 2 in Montana's Mount Haggin Wildlife Management Area.
Fluvial Arctic Grayling
Fluvial Arctic Grayling
It's unusual to see Park Service personnel, or anyone, in Yellowstone National Park carrying a weapon. But this summer a crew used an air rifle to shoot darts to collect DNA samples from bison. The sampling is a small part of the work being conducted as the animals are considered for protection under the Endangered Species Act.
Bison close up in a snow storm in Yellowstone National Park.
Bison herd with calves in Lamar Valley of Yellowstone National Park.
A herd of bison in Yellowstone National Park.
A bison cow and calf walk in the road in Yellowstone National Park.
A herd of bison move through the Lamar Valley in Yellowstone National Park.
Cow and calf run through the sage in Lamar Valley in Yellowstone National Park.
The ancient bison, Bison antiquus, was taller, had longer horns, and was 25% more massive than living American bison (Bison bison). It was roughly 7.5 feet tall and 15 feet long, weighing approximately 3,500 pounds. Bison had bone horn cores on their skull that served as a base for a longer horn made of keratin, the protein that makes up our fingernails. The span of the horns of Bison antiquus was approximately 3 feet.
Attorney and former Boone and Crockett Club president Lowell Baier spent seven years compiling the "Codex of the Endangered Species Act," reviewing its 50 years of impact.
Fish, Wildlife & Parks repopulation project of Arctic Grayling Repopulation into French Creek.
Wesley Sarmento, prairie bear specialist for Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks, left, talks with Jennie and Seth Becker on the Stickleg Ranch outside Conrad, Mont. in Sept. 2023.
